When it comes to compact and versatile construction equipment, the Case 1845 and 1845C skid steer loaders are two popular options. But what exactly sets these two models apart?
In this blog post, we’ll discuss and summarize the major differences between the Case 1845 and case 1845c skid steer loader.
Knowing the differences can help you decide which model is the better fit for your needs.
We’ve broken down the key differences into an easy-to-read table:
|188 cu. inch Case engine
|More powerful 3.9L Cummins diesel engine
|3-speed hydrostatic Allows greater maneuverability
|Superior hydraulic capacity
|2x as many attachments Increased versatility
As you can see, the 1845C has a more powerful engine, better transmission, improved hydraulics, greater lift capacity, and offers more attachments. This makes it the more advanced model overall.
Throughout the rest of this post, we’ll explore these key differences in more detail. We’ll also look at user reviews and pricing information to help you determine if the older 1845 or newer 1845C is the better fit.
The Case 1845 and 1845C have an interesting history:
- The Case 1845 was first launched in 1975 as a compact skid steer loader built for construction and landscaping use. Its key features were:
- Small, maneuverable size for tight spaces
- Pioneering compact loader design
- A decade later in 1985, Case improved on the 1845 by introducing the 1845C model. This upgraded version included:
- A larger Cummins diesel engine with more power
- Enhanced hydraulics system
- Expanded attachment options
- The 1845C was a significant release for Case, showing their commitment to innovation. It had:
- Increased lift capacity
- Greater versatility
- The 1845C remained in production until 2001, proving the lasting value of its upgraded design.
- Technical Specifications
When looking at the technical specifications of the Case 1845 and 1845C case skid steer loaders, some key differences stand out:
Engines and Power
- The Case 1845 is powered by a 188 cu. inch Case engine, providing 49 hp gross and 45 hp net power at 2200 rpm.
- The 1845C features a larger 3.9L Cummins diesel engine, generating 60 hp gross and 56 hp net power at 2100 rpm like 1840.
- The 1845C’s engine outputs more horsepower at lower rpm, giving it better performance.
Size and Weights
- The operating weight of the 1845 is 5825-5965 lbs depending on engine.
- The 1845C has a higher operating weight of 6085 lbs.
- The 1845C is larger in overall size. Dimensions are:
- Length with bucket: 122 inches
- Height to top of cab: 75 inches
- The 1845 is more compact and lighter.
- The 1845 has a rated operating capacity of 1500 lbs.
- The 1845C has a 175 lb higher rated operating capacity of 1750 lbs.
- The 1845C also has superior hydraulic flow and pressure. It handles 16 gpm at 2300 psi, vs 15.5 gpm at 2250 psi for the 1845.
- Travel speed is faster in the 1845C at 7.5 mph, compared to 6.2 mph in the 1845.
Features and Benefits
Case 1845 Features
- Compact size allows use in tight spaces
- Maneuverable design for versatility
- 188 cu. inch Case gas or diesel engine options
- 2-speed hydrostatic transmission
- 14 compatible attachments like buckets, forks, brooms
- Simple mechanical throttle and linkage controls
- Open operator cab with seatbelt for safety
Case 1845C Advantages
- More powerful 3.9L Cummins diesel engine
- 3-speed hydrostatic transmission allows greater precision
- Superior hydraulic capacity – 16 gpm flow and 2300 psi
- Higher rated operating capacity of 1750 lbs
- Over 30 compatible attachments for increased versatility
- Enclosed cab with better visibility and optional heat
- Glow plugs for better cold weather starting
- The 1845C has better engine power, hydraulics, lift capacity
- The 1845 is lighter and more compact
- The 1845C offers faster speeds and more attachment options
- The 1845 controls are simpler and easier to operate
- The 1845C cab provides more operator comfort and safety
Overall, the 1845C is the more advanced model with better performance, while the 1845 provides a more back-to-basics skid steer experience.
The hydraulic systems differ noticeably between the Case 1845 and 1845C models.
The 1845 has a hydraulic pump flow capacity of 15.5 gallons per minute (gpm) and a system pressure of 2250 pounds per square inch (psi).
Meanwhile, the 1845C offers superior hydraulics with a flow capacity of 16 gpm and a higher system pressure of 2300 psi.
This translated into greater lifting capacities for the 1845C. It can lift 3445 lbs to maximum height, compared to 2920 lbs for the gas-powered 1845 or 3120 lbs for the diesel 1845.
The increased hydraulic performance allows the 1845C to use a wider variety of attachments. Over 30 attachments are compatible with the 1845C, whereas the 1845 supports about 14 attachments.
Overall, the hydraulic improvements in the 1845C provide more productivity and versatility. The higher flow rate and pressure allow the 1845C to operate larger attachments with greater efficiency. This expanded attachment compatibility also increases the tasks the 1845C can take on.
The 1845 is still capable, but its limited hydraulics constrain the size of attachments it can utilize and how quickly it can operate them. The 1845C’s superior hydraulics give owners more productivity options.
Cab and Controls
The cabs and controls differ between the models:
- The 1845 has an open operator cab with a seatbelt for safety. Controls consist of mechanical foot pedals and a manual throttle linkage.
- The 1845C has an enclosed cab offering more comfort. It includes optional features like heat and air conditioning. The 1845C also has better all-around visibility with a wider glass enclosure. Digital controls add precision.
The 1845 provides basic controls and protection for the operator. But the enclosed cab of the 1845C allows operators to work in greater comfort across more weather conditions.
The digital controls in the 1845C also improve the precision of operations. The mechanical controls of the 1845 are simple to use but lack the responsiveness and accuracy of electronic controls.
The 1845 and 1845C differ significantly in their attachment compatibility and versatility:
- The 1845 works with around 14 attachments like buckets, forks, brooms.
- The 1845C is compatible with over 30 attachments, including augers, grapples, snow blowers and more.
The wider variety of attachments supported by the 1845C makes it substantially more versatile. The 1845C can take on tasks like drilling holes, clearing snow, or lifting loads.
Meanwhile, the 1845’s narrower attachment options limit its application range. Owners may need separate equipment to handle tasks the 1845C can complete directly with attachments.
Overall, the 1845C’s expansive attachment compatibility gives owners greater versatility and value from a single machine.
Operationally, the 1845 and 1845C have some key variances:
The 1845 is simpler and easier to use straight out of the box. Its manual foot pedals and throttle linkage provide basic controls anyone can quickly master. Its smaller size also allows the 1845 to maneuver into tighter spaces.
However, the 1845C offers greater precision and responsiveness with its electronic controls. The 3-speed transmission also gives the 1845C better traction and maneuverability through challenging terrain. The larger Cummins engine provides more power for heavy digging or pushing.
Maintenance needs are similar, but parts are more readily available for the 1845C since it was manufactured and sold in larger numbers more recently. Both models require regular service of fluids, filters, and wear parts.
Overall, the 1845 is the simpler machine to operate, while the 1845C brings more raw power and precision at the cost of slightly more complex controls. In the long-run, the 1845C’s advanced features improve performance but some may prefer the easier operation of the 1845.
Price and Availability
Since both the 1845 and 1845C are discontinued, they must be purchased used. Availability favors the 1845C since it was manufactured more recently.
Pricing also varies:
- Well-maintained used 1845 models tend to cost $8,000 – $12,000.
- Used 1845C models range from $12,000 – $18,000.
The 1845C commands a higher price due to having better performance specs and more demand. Many contractors specifically search for a used 1845C over an 1845.
The 1845 provides cost savings for buyers willing to accept the older technology. But overall demand is lower for the 1845, making it harder to find in good condition.
Considering the pricing differential, buyers wanting greater capability may view the 1845C as well worth the extra investment. The 1845 serves as a more budget-friendly option for basic needs.
User Reviews and Feedback
Looking at user reviews reveals some common perspectives on these loaders:
Owners praise the 1845 for its simple and sturdy design. Its compact size receives positive feedback for fitting into smaller work sites. However, some users wish the 1845 had more power and lift capacity. There are also complaints about the lack of an enclosed cab.
Meanwhile, reviews praise the 1845C for its much improved power from the larger Cummins engine. Users are also pleased with the 3-speed transmission and smooth electronic controls. The wider range of attachments receives positive marks for increased versatility. Criticisms focus mainly on the higher initial cost.
In general, buyers seem satisfied with the basic performance and ease of use of the 1845. More demanding owners need the enhanced engine power, precision controls, and attachment flexibility the 1845C provides.
Given the choice, veterans strongly recommend spending extra for a used 1845C over the older 1845 model. The advanced features allow the 1845C to take on more tasks and work more efficiently. But budget buyers can still achieve core skid steer duties with the 1845.
Conclusion case 1845c vs 1845c
In summary, the key differences between the Case 1845 and 1845C come down to improved performance and technology in the 1845C model. The 1845C offers a more powerful engine, superior hydraulics, greater lift capacity, more attachment options, and an enclosed cab with precise controls. This makes it the more productive and versatile model overall.
For buyers needing maximum capability, the additional cost of a used 1845C is likely worth the investment. Budget-focused buyers can still get basic performance from the older 1845. But for only moderate savings, most owners would be better served by the 1845C long-term due to its advantages in power and versatility. If you’re looking for more comparison articles, check out this post on the differences between the Ford Bronco and Bronco Sport.